28 Aug
The Inn at Buck Hill Falls
Author: Brianna Williams
While driving around one evening years ago, I stumbled upon a community I never knew existed. I can only describe it as alluring, haunting and magical. From very high, dangerously curving roads, to sprawling stone homes that look ancient and yet are in incredible repair-to charming cottages from an old time postcard, it is truly a place that time forgot. Gaping at the beauty and somewhat other worldly preservation, I half expected to see a Laura Ingalls look a like and a hobbit or two. Though it seemed the stuff of an acid trip filled movie, soberly enchanted, I continued on.
About two hours from Manhattan and Philly, comprised of a staggering 4,500 acres of land, is the private resort community of Buck Hill Falls.
Drenched in breathtaking architecture and sadly the ruins of time, a majestic Inn sits amongst sprawling hills and rich foliage in the heart of the Pocono Mountains. This is her story.
Designed to be a Haven for the elite, The Inn at Buck Hill Falls was the vacation destination of choice for many a wealthy family and, in it’s day, was nothing short of magnificent. The community has a 27 hole Donald Ross golf course, its own post office and several other luxurious amenities.
Starting out as a quaint Quaker retreat in 1901, she made her debut as a grandiose stone Inn for the affluent in 1926. Upon closing the doors in 1991, the Inn at Buck Hill encompassed an impressive 400+ rooms over an expanse of 134 breathtaking acres.
Reading that this place was haunted did not surprise me in the least, you can feel the energy is off by merely looking at it. The fact that something is amiss radiates in the air around Buck Hill Falls.
What I was not prepared for was the tragic history.
According to “Pennsylvania Haunts & History”
“…It was supposed to be a place that the Mob liked to frequent, and the owners were more than willing to bend a rule or three themselves. It’s said that in 66 years of operation, 73 people died at the hotel. Five, in fact, died in one room, #354.
A bride named Lorna Kilpatrick was murdered there by the very priest that married her the day before at the resort. He committed suicide, and Lorna’s ghost has haunted the room ever since. A maid slit her wrists in there while clutching a rosary. People refused to stay in the room because of the constant freezing cold, doors that wouldn’t stay shut – and the ghosts. The hotel had to shut the room permanently.
There’s a small room in the basement that’s spooked by the spirit of an accountant who was supposedly murdered there. He was cooking the books and the owner found out. One bathroom saw three murders committed in it, and was haunted by a ghost evoked in a seance gone haywire. It had to be exorcised, and poltergeist activity still took place in the restroom.
A maid’s closet was the scene of a strangulation, and it was said you could hear the maid gasp and her labored breathing and death rattle afterwards. The spook of an elderly soldier in an old uniform was reported wandering in the servants quarter’s on the third floor. He has a gaping hole in his chest from a musket wound. He once strolled through a garden party and then vanished.
An Indian spirit has been seen roaming the area, too. In fact, the Native Americans believed the whole area was evil. Certain psychics agree, saying the East Room is the center of lay lines that mark evil. It may be. One owner’s wife used to sleep in a room where the lines converged. She ended up schizophrenic.
There are also lots of poltergeist activities. One guard said during his nightly rounds lights would go on and doors open in buildings that he had secured earlier. Some guests reported hearing voices, shaking beds, opening and shutting widows, electrical devices going off on their own, and ghost sightings – even of spooks hovering over their bed.
http://hauntsandhistory.blogspot.com/2008/02/buck-hill-inn.html
How’s that for a menacing past? My very first thought was that all of this sounded just as good, if not better, than Stephen King’s “The Shining.”
So what ever became of the Inn at Buck Hill Falls?
As if the past had come back to haunt it, the Inn experienced great financial hardship, leaving it abandoned. While sitting dormant, it became the victim of arson. A once exquisite site now hazardous and in disarray, had become the stuff of B Horror movies and sadder still, reality TV.
In 2001 the Inn at Buck Hill Falls made an appearance on MTV’s Fear and subsequently gained notoriety. To this day, security is in place to keep trespassers from entering the ailing structure. According to a 2006 article from the Pocono Record newspaper, Barrett township police and the company which owns the property are strictly enforcing 90 days in jail or a $300 fine to anyone caught. Bollocks! My plans have been shattered.
http://www.poconorecord.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20061028/NEWS01/610280317/-1/NEWS
The video below offers clips of the Fear episode.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ho5tZsl4GoI
Given the fact that so many people gathered here for so many years, I’d say it is fairly safe to assume that paranormal activity exists. As I said before, the whole area, while beautiful, has a Twilight Zone feel to it. Living a few miles away, I could not wait to write about it, even if that had to be in lieu of an investigation.
So believe me when I say that I wanted this story to be true. Ah, but wishing doesn’t make it so. As is often the case, if it sounds to good to be true, it probably is. While there may be spirits, it seems producers ran a compelling story with very little basis in truth. I was unable to find any evidence at all which supports the claims made in the article above. Perhaps that due to the location’s connections and social status, such claims were not documented. However, when it comes to murder and suicide, one would hope to find something to support an event of that magnitude.
If walls could talk…
One of the current owners of The Buck Hill Inn, which was featured on last week’s episode of Fear, says that the haunted history presented on the show was, at best, embellished. “I don’t think MTV’s intention was ever to accurately portray the building’s history,” William Kirkhuff told the Pocono Record. He says psychics found only “happy spirits,” and thus the “producers got a little frustrated when they were trying to tape a show called Fear and there wasn’t any to be had, according to the psychics.” The newspaper looks at some claims made on the show and refutes them.
http://www.realityblurred.com/realitytv/archives/fear/2001_Mar_19_buck_hill_inn_owner
All of this could easily have been avoided if the kind folks at MTV would just go back to playing some damn music videos.
For those interested in more information on Buck Hill Falls, including the opportunity to purchase and restore the Inn:
http://www.buckhillinn.com/history.html
A very detailed account on haunting claims and history:
Article explaining the actual investigation and the how it differs from what was aired on the show:
http://www.paraseek.com/invest/weaver2.html
Thank you for reading. If you have information to contribute to the content of this post, especially accounts of those who stayed there-or any verifiable data pertaining to said traumatic history, please email me at brianna@epicparanormal.com
Filed under: Haunted Locations, Inns



